First of all, I know it's not even close to Christmas, but I've been looking forward to sharing this idea for the past couple days.
Some may think it's redundant for me to do another Christmas story since I already have Boris and Chloe, but this is basically intended as an affectionate parody of a lot of the classic Christmas specials, like from Rankin-Bass and what not. I've come up with a whole bunch of individual ideas, each parodying a different element of Christmas specials, and hope to tie them together as best I can.
So, we've all seen that trope of cartoon reindeer who look more like white-tailed deer, and I've been wanting to reference that for a while. Here, we have a white-tailed doe who lives with Santa's reindeer and believes herself to be a reindeer despite the fact that she's the only one who doesn't have antlers. Maybe part of the story has her hoping she's just a late-bloomer and she'll grow antlers eventually.
I was thinking of a way to parody the Christmas elves, with the idea of them being slaves being an obvious one. Then I thought it would be funny if one of the elves was a tall Tolkien-style elf who resembles Legolas in appearance and behavior. Maybe he's tired of this toy-making bullshit and wants to go out and do real elf things with his bow and arrow.
I also want to throw in a talking snowman as another character. I was wondering what kind of black comedy jokes I could tell with him, but a lot of existential snowman jokes I can think of have already been done by Frozen. I remembered how in Frosty the Snowman, the titular character was all surprised about his new sentience and assumed it was a joke, as if he was aware he was a thing that should not be, so maybe I can do something similar with this snowman (maybe also stealing from Forky in Toy Story 4 as well), where he's all like "Why am I moving? Why am I talking? I'm not supposed to be sentient! I'm an abomination!" I could also throw in references to Calvin's snowmen in Calvin and Hobbes (including the infamous snow goons story), and maybe as a reference to Frosty saying "Happy birthday!" whenever he comes to life, I could have this snowman say "Happy deathday!" when he melts.
I was also thinking of that trope where there's penguins in the North Pole, and wanted to reference that as well. My first idea was a penguin who is lost (similar to Topper from Santa Claus is Comin' to Town), but then I thought it would be interesting if this character was a great auk who was annoyed that so many people were mistaking them for a penguin. (Which is especially funny since the term "penguin" was originally used for the great auk before being used for real penguins, despite the fact that the two birds aren't related and only look similar due to convergent evolution). To top it off, maybe this character wears a hat and scarf like so many cartoon penguins wear.
Anyway, this story could probably be a big satire of how commercialized Christmas has become in later years (complete with a jab at those awful Poopsie toys), where Santa himself has become so disillusioned to the true meaning of Christmas that he makes toys entirely for profit. I knew I had to throw Krampus into this, and I could've had him as the main villain, but I think enough Americans are familiar with Krampus nowadays due to the horror movie of the same name that having him as a good guy would be an interesting subversion.
Anyway, I imagine Krampus leaving is the reason Christmas became so commercialized, since there's no one to punish the spoiled kids, and the demands of the spoiled kids is what caused commercialism to fester. It's also the reason most people don't believe in Santa either, and the few who do just see him as a guy who just gives away toys to anyone regardless of whether or not they earned it. Also, instead of going into houses like he used to, he just delivers the toys directly to toy companies. (This is a way to rectify how in Christmas movies, adults don't believe in Santa despite toys mysteriously showing up during the night, as well as acknowledging how in older folklore, Krampus directly interacts with children even though you're not supposed to see Santa.)
Anyway, I'm thinking the conflict of the story is kicked off when the Legolas-like elf is tired of commercialism, and after hearing of Krampus, decides to go and bring him back to remind Santa of his original goal, which was to reward the good kids and punish the bad kids, which will bring the original meaning of Christmas back. The white-tailed doe accompanies him, and maybe the snowman and auk join him as well. I'm thinking Krampus is built up throughout the story as a horrifying demon, only to turn out to be a pretty nice guy when off-duty.
I'm thinking one scene will have the doe encounter a moose and a wapiti who are arguing over which of them is a real elk (since the term "elk" was originally used for moose before being used for wapiti), before the doe tells them they can both be elk, which is what tells her she can still be a reindeer despite not being a caribou.
Oh! And I have to have an abominable snow man at one point. I could reference the Looney Tunes yeti by having him constantly pick up and cuddle any small animal he sees. ("Just what I always wanted, my own little penguin!" "I AIN'T NO PENGUIN!") Maybe that could be one way Krampus threatens the bad kids in the end. And yes, of COURSE his name will be George.
What do you guys think? Any suggestions? Should I add this to my Google Doc of upcoming story ideas, along with Hominids?